Disclaimer: BeautyKiln gives general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Talk to a qualified professional before making big decisions.

What Happens When a Client Claims Against You

It's the phone call, email or letter that every beauty professional dreads. A client says you caused them harm. Maybe it's an allergic reaction. Maybe it's a burn. Maybe it's damage they say happened during a treatment. Whatever it is, your stomach drops and your first instinct is to panic, apologise, offer a refund, or both.

Don't. How you handle the first 48 hours after a complaint can determine whether your insurer covers you, whether the claim escalates, and whether you end up paying out of your own pocket. This guide walks you through exactly what happens - step by step - from the moment a client complains to the final outcome.

Quick rule of thumb: Don't admit fault. Don't offer money. Document everything. Call your insurer. Let them handle it.

Step 1: The client complains

It usually starts in one of three ways:

• Face to face or by phone: The client contacts you directly, upset about the result of a treatment. They might be angry, tearful, or calm and factual. However they present it, listen carefully.
• In writing: An email, text message, or letter setting out what happened and what they want.
• Through a solicitor: If the first thing you receive is a letter from a law firm, the client has already decided to make a formal claim. This goes straight to your insurer.

At this stage, the client might want anything from a redo to a refund to financial compensation. Your response matters.

Step 2: Do NOT admit fault

This is the single most important rule.

Do not say:

• "I'm so sorry, it must have been my fault"
• "I must have left the product on too long"
• "I knew I should have done a patch test"
• "Let me give you a refund to make up for it"

You can say:

• "I'm sorry to hear you're not happy with the result"
• "I take this very seriously and I want to look into it properly"
• "Can you tell me exactly what happened and when?"
• "I need to check my records and speak to my insurer before I can respond fully"

Why does this matter? Because in insurance terms, admitting fault - even casually, even sympathetically - can prejudice your insurer's ability to defend the claim. If you say "it was my fault" and the insurer later investigates and finds it wasn't, your admission makes the claim much harder to defend. Some policies explicitly state that admitting liability without the insurer's consent can void your cover.

Being sympathetic is fine. Being professional is fine. Saying "this is my fault, here's some money" is not fine.

Tip for new starters: Practise what you'd say if a client complained right now. Have a calm, professional response ready in your head before you ever need it. Under pressure, people default to apologising and admitting fault. Having a prepared response stops you saying something that could void your insurance.

Step 3: Document everything

From the moment a client raises a concern, start documenting. Write down:

• The date and time the client contacted you
• What they said - as close to their exact words as you can remember
• How they contacted you (phone, text, email, in person)
• What treatment was performed and when
• What products were used (brand, type, batch number if you have it)
• Whether a patch test was done and the date
• Your consultation card / treatment record for that client
• Any photos - of the client's complaint (with their permission), of your workspace, of the products used

If the complaint is about a visible injury (burn, rash, swelling, skin damage), ask the client if they'll send you photos. If you took before-and-after photos as part of your normal process, find them.

Keep screenshots of all text messages and emails. Don't delete anything. Print copies if you can.

Your consultation card is your best friend. If you did a patch test and recorded it, if you noted the client's medical history and allergies, if you documented the products and timings - that's your evidence that you followed proper procedure. If you didn't keep proper records, you've just made it much harder to defend yourself.

Tip for new starters: Fill in your consultation card before and after every single treatment, even for regulars. The one time you skip it will be the one time something goes wrong. A complete consultation card is the difference between your insurer covering you and leaving you on your own.

Step 4: Notify your insurer

Contact your insurer as soon as possible - ideally within 24 to 48 hours of becoming aware of the complaint. Most policies require prompt notification of any incident that might lead to a claim. Delay can give the insurer grounds to refuse cover.

What to tell them:

• Your policy number
• The date of the treatment
• The date the client complained
• A summary of what happened
• What the client is asking for
• Any documentation you have (consultation card, photos, messages)

Your insurer will open a file and assign a claims handler. From this point, the insurer takes the lead. You don't need to negotiate with the client, respond to their solicitor, or make any decisions about money. That's what you're paying premiums for.

What if you're not sure it will become a formal claim? Notify your insurer anyway. It's always better to report an incident that goes nowhere than to not report one that escalates. Many policies require you to report any incident that "might reasonably give rise to a claim" - not just actual claims.

Step 5: The insurer investigates

Once notified, your insurer will:

1. Review your policy to confirm the treatment and location are covered
2. Request your documentation - consultation cards, treatment records, photos, correspondence with the client
3. Assess the client's complaint - what are they claiming happened, and what are they asking for?
4. May appoint a loss adjuster or investigator for larger or more complex claims
5. May ask you for a written statement about what happened during the treatment

During the investigation, cooperate fully. Answer their questions honestly. Provide every document they ask for. Don't withhold information, even if you think it makes you look bad - your insurer is on your side, and withholding information can void your cover.

Step 6: The insurer handles correspondence

From now on, all communication with the client (or their solicitor) goes through your insurer. You do not need to respond directly to the client's demands, threats, or legal letters. If the client contacts you directly, tell them: "I've passed this to my insurer. They'll be in contact with you."

If the client's solicitor contacts you, forward everything to your insurer immediately. Do not respond to legal letters yourself. Do not sign anything. Do not agree to anything.

Step 7: Possible outcomes

The claim is settled

Your insurer agrees to pay the client a sum of money to resolve the claim. This is the most common outcome for smaller claims (under £5,000). It's usually cheaper for the insurer to settle than to fight it in court, even if you did nothing wrong. This can feel frustrating - you may feel like you're admitting fault when you're not - but a settlement is not an admission of liability. It's a business decision by the insurer.

You pay your excess (the amount you agreed to pay per claim when you took out the policy - typically £100-500). The insurer pays the rest.

The claim is defended

If the insurer believes you have a strong defence (proper records, patch test done, correct products used, proper technique followed), they may defend the claim. This means pushing back on the client's allegations and, if necessary, going to court.

This is more common for larger claims or claims where the insurer believes the client's version of events is inaccurate.

The claim goes to court

Most beauty claims don't end up in court. But if the client and insurer can't agree, it can go to a small claims court (for claims up to £10,000) or a county court (for larger amounts). Your insurer appoints solicitors to represent you. You may need to attend court and give evidence, but your insurer manages the process.

The claim is withdrawn

Sometimes clients make complaints in the heat of the moment and don't follow through. The insurer keeps the file open for a period (usually 6-12 months) and then closes it if nothing further happens.

The claim is denied by your insurer

If your insurer finds that the treatment wasn't covered by your policy, or that you breached the terms of your policy (e.g., performing a treatment you're not qualified for, not having done a patch test when your policy requires it), they can deny the claim. This means you're on your own - personally liable for whatever the client is claiming.

This is why it's critical to keep your policy up to date, only perform treatments you're qualified and insured for, and follow proper procedures every single time.

Your obligations during a claim

What NOT to do

Don't discuss the claim on social media

Do not post about the claim on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, Twitter, or anywhere else. Do not subtly reference it ("some people are so ungrateful"). Do not respond to the client's posts about it. Anything you say publicly can be used in the claim - and your insurer will not be happy if you've been broadcasting details of an active claim.

If the client posts a bad review or makes public accusations, screenshot everything (for your insurer) and do not respond publicly. Tell your insurer. They'll advise you.

Don't offer a refund without insurer approval

Your instinct might be to offer a refund to make the problem go away. Don't - not without talking to your insurer first. A refund can be interpreted as an admission that something went wrong. It can also set a precedent that encourages the client to push for more.

If your insurer agrees that a goodwill refund is the best way to resolve it, they'll tell you. Let them make that call.

Don't contact the client to "sort it out"

Once you've notified your insurer, let them handle the communication. Calling the client to apologise, explain, or negotiate can make things worse. You might say something that undermines your defence. The client might record the call. Your insurer might lose the ability to defend you.

How long does it take?

Claims can take anywhere from a few weeks to over a year to resolve. Small claims (£500-2,000) often settle within 2-4 months. Larger claims or disputed claims can take 6-18 months. Court cases take even longer.

During this time, you can continue working normally. An open claim does not suspend your insurance or prevent you from practising. But the uncertainty and stress are real - which brings us to the next point.

The emotional impact

Let's be honest: having a client claim against you is horrible. Even if you did everything right. Even if the claim is baseless. You'll question yourself, lose sleep, and feel sick every time you think about it.

This happens to good practitioners. It happens to experienced practitioners. It happens to people who follow every procedure perfectly. Allergic reactions can happen despite patch tests. Skin can react unpredictably. Clients can have unrealistic expectations. Some complaints are genuine; some are opportunistic.

Having insurance means you're not facing it alone. Your insurer deals with claims every day. They have solicitors, investigators, and claims handlers who do this for a living. Let them carry the weight.

If the stress is affecting your mental health, talk to someone. The Samaritans (116 123), your GP, or a therapist. The beauty industry can feel isolating when things go wrong - but you are not alone and this is not the end of your career.

When it's NOT an insurance claim

Not every unhappy client is an insurance claim. Some situations are complaints, not claims:

Unhappy with a style or result. The client doesn't like their hair colour, thinks their lashes are too long, or wanted a different shape to their brows. No injury, no damage, just disappointment. This is a customer service issue, not an insurance claim. You decide whether to offer a redo, a partial refund, or nothing - this is a business decision, not an insurance matter.

Complaint to Trading Standards. A client reports you to Trading Standards for misleading advertising, poor hygiene, or product safety concerns. This is a regulatory matter. Trading Standards may inspect your premises, ask questions, or issue improvement notices. It's not an insurance claim (unless Trading Standards' involvement leads to a compensation claim from the client).

Bad online review. A client leaves a negative review on Google, Facebook or Trustpilot. Upsetting, but not an insurance claim. You can respond professionally (without discussing any treatment details - GDPR applies), report the review if it contains false statements, or simply leave it. Do not get into a public argument.

Request for a refund only. If a client just wants their money back and isn't claiming injury or damage, this is a commercial decision. You can offer a refund, a redo, a partial refund, or nothing. Your insurer doesn't need to be involved unless the client is also alleging harm.

What to do next

• Review your insurance policy now. Check the claims notification procedure - how quickly must you notify them? What information do they need?
• Save your insurer's claims line phone number in your phone. When you need it, you'll need it fast.
• Make sure your consultation cards and treatment records are up to date for every client, every treatment. This is your first line of defence.
• Take before-and-after photos where appropriate (with client consent). Store them securely.
• Keep a simple incident log - any complaint, any reaction, any concern, no matter how small. Note the date, client, treatment, and outcome.

Who to Contact

• Your insurer's claims line - the number on your policy documents. Save it in your phone now.
• Citizens Advice - free guidance on consumer complaints and your rights: citizensadvice.org.uk - 0800 144 8848 (Free)
• Samaritans - if the stress is affecting your mental health: 116 123 (Free, 24/7)
• National Hair & Beauty Federation (NHBF) - legal helpline for members: nhbf.co.uk (Free for members)
• Your professional body (ABT, BABTAC, FHT) - many offer support and advice for members facing claims (Free for members)
• A solicitor - if your insurer denies cover and you need independent legal advice (Paid)
• ICO - if there are data protection issues around shared client records: ico.org.uk - 0303 123 1113 (Free)
• ACAS - if the claim involves an employment status dispute: acas.org.uk - 0300 123 1100 (Free)

Sources

• Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) - insurance claims handling rules (ICOBS)
• Association of British Insurers (ABI) - claims process guidance
• Citizens Advice - consumer complaints and compensation
• NHBF - guidance on handling client complaints
• ICO - GDPR guidance on sharing client information

Related Guides

• Treatment Risk vs Public Liability: Know the Difference
• Insurance for Chair Renters
• Insurance by Specialism
• Working From Multiple Locations: Insurance Gaps
• Cancellation and No-Show Policies

📢 Sponsorship available — Learn more

What to do next

Didn't find what you were looking for?